Author Topic: The weed and carp safety  (Read 373 times)

hursty

  • Global Moderator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 434
    • View Profile
    • It's grim up north
The weed and carp safety
« on: September 21, 2008, 10:34:22 AM »
I'm sure that we all agree that we are lucky enough to be angling for some of the prettiest carp in the region albeit not the largest (size isn't everything apparently) , they are also in superb condition which is a credit to lads who catch and look after them whilst on the mat . If we wish to keep them in tip top shape then I feel that something needs to be done about the conditions in which we angle for them.
      Let me state that this is not a gripe about not being able to fish effectively with the current level of weed growth as I am more than happy to fish in the margins where more often than not I can present a bait without  hindrance from the weed. Its what happens after this that I find the problem , more often than not if I am fortunate enough to get a pick up the carp will soon be weeded up. If the weed is not too dense then the carp can be coaxed out but this is not the norm , usually the weed is thick and a tug of war usually ensues. I am no fish scientist but I am certain that this places uneccessary stress on the fish let alone the damage caused to their mouths and flanks. Having fished elsewhere and seen the state of the carp where weed and lilly growth has dictated that they have been angled for in for less severe conditions than we are faced with, I fear the worst for the carp in Ravenfield.                                       
       I get the feeling that the current committee regard the carp anglers as something of a nuisance and disregard our pleas regarding the control of the weed . I am sure that one or two of them will have sneaky read of this (why not register and have the right to reply?) and I am certain that they are just as concerned about the welfare of the carp as we carp anglers are . So , for the sake of the carp if nothing else lets get something done .Afterall , the committee quite happily takes our annual fee , a little reinvestment  of our fees isn't too much to ask for.
yid army!

stufish

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 61
    • View Profile
    • Turnedwritepens
Re: The weed and carp safety
« Reply #1 on: September 21, 2008, 05:38:29 PM »
I couldn't agree more with your sentiments. I have made very similar ones myself in posts on this site before.

Fish welfare should be the No.1 consideration for all anglers - whether carp or match. I have personally witnessed far too many fish banked at Ravenfield that has had scales ripped off, or mouths shredded, due to being dragged through thirty yards of choking weed before being netted. This can also leave the fish absolutely drained - not good in the middle of summer with low oxygen levels in the water.

As for the committee being concerned about carp welfare - well, I think you might re-evaluate your comment if you read some of Adi's posts, in which he relates communication with certain members of the committee.

Ravenfield is a glorious place to fish. It could be a real jewel amongst carp waters. Yet how many members are going to rejoin next season after this year's debacle? We are paying our yearly fees, yet are getting about five months worth of fishing, if we're lucky - and that's throughout the colder months, when bites dry up and banking a fish becomes something of a rarity. Not good value for money in my book.

I personally believe that Ravenfield carp lake will be lucky to get more than a dozen members next year. Any takers on that bet?

hursty

  • Global Moderator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 434
    • View Profile
    • It's grim up north
Re: The weed and carp safety
« Reply #2 on: September 21, 2008, 05:52:18 PM »
just another point regarding the carps welfare and the weed . It is a well known fact that although canadian pondweed is an oxygenating plant , it only produces oxygen during daylight and in darkness it does the opposite. That's right , youve guessed it . During darkness it actually releases C02 into the pond , so during the summer when oxygen levels are low anyway these huge beds of weed are depleting it further. Not conducive to happy carp I think you'll agree , but what do I know ?
yid army!